Archbishop Cherry Vann Responds to Criticism Over Sexuality: “I Cannot See How It’s Wrong”

Archbishop Cherry Vann, recently elected as the Archbishop of Wales, has made history as the first openly lesbian primate within the Anglican Communion. Her appointment follows a period of intense scrutiny and debate both within the Church and among its global community. Critics, particularly from conservative Anglican circles, have expressed alarm, asserting that her election signals a departure from traditional doctrine. In response, Vann has spoken publicly, affirming her commitment to her faith, her partner, and the evolving understanding of love and inclusion within Christianity .

Cherry Vann’s election as Archbishop of Wales marks a significant milestone for LGBTQ+ representation in religious leadership. Living in a same-sex partnership, Vann is now the first openly gay bishop to serve as a primate in the Anglican Communion, a position that has drawn both celebration and condemnation .

Conservative groups such as the Global Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans (Gafcon) have been vocal in their opposition. Dr. Laurent Mbanda, Archbishop of the Anglican Church of Rwanda and chair of Gafcon, described her appointment as “another painful nail in the coffin of Anglican orthodoxy,” arguing that the Church in Wales had “bowed to worldly pressure that subverts God’s good word” . Similarly, the Global South Fellowship of Anglican Churches (GSFA) issued statements expressing grief and disappointment, citing concerns that the election “tears the fabric of our beloved Communion” .

In interviews with Premier Christian News, Archbishop Vann addressed the criticism directly. She stated, “Christians hold different views on all manner of subjects: divorce, remarriage, abortion, assisted dying, to name but a few. I mean, we are not all of one mind on most things. And you know, the Church changes its position. It learns a broader understanding of God’s love” .

Vann further emphasized her personal faith journey, remarking, “I have never heard God say to me, ‘who you are is wrong, who you love is wrong, you are living in sin.’ I have never heard that from God, and that’s all I can say” . She argued that biblical passages traditionally used to condemn same-sex relationships referred specifically to abusive or exploitative contexts, not loving consensual partnerships.

Vann’s appointment has been met with support from various LGBTQ+ organizations and progressive voices within the Anglican Communion. Many see her leadership as a sign of long-overdue change and a step toward inclusion and equality within faith communities. Her participation in events such as Pride Cymru and her advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights have further solidified her position as a trailblazer for visibility and acceptance .

The Church in Wales has notably declined to formally respond to criticism, suggesting an institutional commitment to diversity and evolving perspectives on human sexuality .

The controversy surrounding Archbishop Vann’s election underscores broader divides within the Anglican Communion, particularly between more progressive national churches and conservative groups in the Global South. While some leaders have called for renewed commitment to traditional teachings, others have welcomed Vann’s example as a reflection of Christianity’s capacity for compassion and inclusivity .

As debates continue, Vann’s leadership is poised to shape the future direction of the Church in Wales, with significant implications for LGBTQ+ clergy and congregants worldwide.